Here at CARE we long to see civility, decency and good debate in our politics. We believe that rigorous debate is a key part of a healthy politics and can help politics to be a great force for good. Sadly, though we often see plenty of examples of bad debate, incivility, and downright poor behaviour.
Each week we will bring you some of our favourite examples of civility, decency, and good debate in our politics, as well as some sad examples of the darker side of politics.
The Good
Perhaps we can be friendly after all…
Not technically part of the election campaign but on Wednesday (before all the election hullaballoo began), Parliament welcomed Craig Mackinlay MP back to Parliament after a life-threatening battle with Sepsis. In a rare display of Parliamentary unity, he received a standing ovation from colleagues on both sides of the House…
Craig Mackinlay receives a standing ovation on his return to the House of Commons.
— Channel 4 News (@Channel4News) May 22, 2024
The Conservative MP's hands and feet had to be amputated after a life-threatening bout of sepsis in September 2023. pic.twitter.com/YmBP8c6D9Z
Armchair politics is easy…
The founder of Blue Beyond, a think tank aimed to engage young conservatives, reminded us all this week that it’s easy to be an armchair politician, but putting yourself forward and getting out on the campaign trail is a tough ask. Perhaps those in the armchairs owe those on the trail a little more respect…
Just wanted to say – whether Tory, Labour and so on – good luck to all standing. Lots of people happy to write tweets, blogs, articles or go on TV to say what they think. Putting yourself forward, listening to people and spending wet evenings canvassing is not easy. Respect.
— Luke 🌳 (@lukerobertblack) May 22, 2024
Spare a thought for the staff…
People often forget that behind the 650 MPs are thousands of staffers who dedicate themselves to case work and the day-to-day tasks that make an MPs office tick including being the first people to see much of the abuse that lands in an MP’s inbox. When an election comes, they too face financial and job uncertainty…
It's been a busy couple of days in parliament (understatement) but something that's often forgotten about is what the general election means for around 3,500 MPs' staff in Westminster and across the country… 🧵
— Dr Rebecca McKee (@RMCMcKee) May 24, 2024
The Bad
Playing the man, not the ball…
We welcome rigorous debates where ideas and claims are held to account. We are less fond of calling MPs “idiots” and “narcissists”…
Newsnight @vicderbyshire taking apart the idiot Steve Baker
— Carol Vorderman (@carolvorders) May 23, 2024
Tory treating us like we're stupid, like we haven't lived through the last 14 years….all the techniques of a narcissist..
Vic taking no prisoners #GeneralElection pic.twitter.com/Nn0WIb3zhd
There’s weak debate, and then there’s fake debate…
Rishi Sunak was accused of faking support after an event in Derbyshire in which two ‘normal people’ from the crowd turned out to be Conservative Party councillors. This doesn’t appear to be an example of public debate being done in good faith…
Rishi Sunak Takes Staged Election Questions from Conservative Councillors Posing as Ordinary Voters https://t.co/2YKSlCebNp pic.twitter.com/qH88qzXly2
— Byline Times (@BylineTimes) May 24, 2024
The Ugly
There’s marches, and then there’s hate marches…
Protesting has a legitimate place in democratic politics but some of the scenes emanating out of protests in Finchley this week were downright unpleasant and abusive.
Swearing, hatred, and abuse were all on display on the streets of North London. We do not condone this kind of behaviour in any form of protest and are not sharing the video for this reason – though you can find clips online should you wish.
What made us laugh…
Politics has its good moments and its bad moments but sometimes it’s just quite funny. Each week we will bring you some of our favourite highlights from the week.
Action Man or Accidental Partridge…
This week’s award goes to Steve Baker MP for this response…
The Rt Hon Steve Baker, Conservative MP for Wycombe & Minister of State for Northern Ireland pic.twitter.com/814aH8GPRv
— K Biswas (@BizK1) May 22, 2024