31 May 2024

What if I don’t agree with every policy from my party?

Share

Leading up to the General Election, each party will launch their manifesto: their policy pledges if they were to be elected to form a government.

As a Christian engaged with politics, I have read many manifestos, attended multiple party conferences, and been given the opportunity to speak to Parliamentarians from all parties. But I have never read a manifesto, attended a political event or met a politician and agreed 100% with what has been written or spoken. And I would be highly surprised and freaked out if I did. The only person I completely agree with is Louise Davies and I am not intending to form a political party or run for elected office anytime soon!

The Bible tells us that we are fearfully and wonderfully made (Psalm 139:14) and that we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works (Ephesians 2:10). God did not create us to be clones but rather to have unique personalities, upbringings and talents. We do not look the same and we do not think the same. And if we do not think the same, then we will not agree on everything.

Even at CARE, although as a staff team we are united in Christ, we have different political leanings to one another. We agree on certain issues such as the beginning and end of life, but we would disagree on economics, foreign policy, welfare, the nationalisation of industries and so on. This disagreement however is not a negative thing. The Bible tells us that “as iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another” (Proverbs 27:17).

In my former role as the Director of Christians on the Left, which is an affiliate organisation of the Labour Party, I often found myself disagreeing with party’s policies on certain issues. A few years ago, a Christian friend rang me to ask why I was still a member of the party and insisted that I should leave. My friend had my best intentions at heart, but I knew something that he didn’t. God had sent me into the Labour Party to be salt and light; it was my mission field.

It would be easier to shout from the sidelines, but if we truly want to engage, we have to show up and speak up. I responded by saying that the darker it gets, the brighter I shine. The choice to stay proved to be the right one. During my time there, I had the opportunity to speak truth to power to shadow ministers and to the leader, to shape policy, and to make a real difference.

It wasn’t the easiest season, and it required prayer and endurance, but for us to be effective we must work within a system that we don’t 100% agree with or align with. Daniel had a similar dilemma as an exile in Babylon. Rather than not engaging with the political system he found himself in, he served the King. He had his red lines which he wasn’t willing to step over, but he did glorify God in a foreign regime.

You will not agree with every policy from a political party. But we must not resign ourselves and disengage, or remove ourselves from the democratic process.

So how do we choose the party to vote for in this General Election? Here are a few tips:

  • Pray for wisdom.
  • Read the manifestos with an open mind.
  • Attend a hustings and pose questions to the various candidates.
  • Discover what you are passionate about. The Bible addresses lots of issues other than sexuality, abortion and assisted suicide. God cares about education, housing, our health system, economics, justice, the most vulnerable in society, asylum seekers, the environment…and so should we.
  • Take our interactive quiz to discover your political leaning.
  • Read our manifesto analysis and blogs from Christians from across the political spectrum.
  • Pray some more.
  • Vote for the person who you think will represent your constituency the best.

I pray that this election might be the springboard for Christians to engage in politics. Could more Christians be salt and light in political parties? We can despair of how parties do not reflect our values, but it would be far better for us to get involved and to actively shape policy ourselves, being led by God’s better story.

by Louise Davies

Louise Davies has been CARE’s Director of Advocacy and Policy since September 2022, having formerly headed up Christians on the Left. She is on the leadership team of her church in Sheffield and has also been the director an anti-trafficking charity.

Share

Sign-up for email updates

We would love to keep you informed about what is happening in politics across the UK from a Christian perspective. The best way to do this is to sign up to receive our weekly email, Impact Direct.

Each week, you will receive Christian commentary on the biggest news story of the week, updates from Westminster and elsewhere in the UK, prayer-points, and great new resources.

We’ve produced some great resources to help you think through your vote.
Prayer is one of the most important things we can do in this election.

Submit your hustings

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Your info.

This is for internal use only (in case we need to contact you about your submission). This won't be published on the site.
Name

Hustings info.

This will appear as the main title on the map listing.
Location
This will be added to the site so that people can get in touch for more info. We will hide the email address so spam bots can't harvest your address.

James 4:17

17If anyone, then, knows the good they ought to do and doesn’t do it, it is sin for them.

Isaiah 9:16

16Those who guide this people mislead them, and those who are guided are led astray.

Genesis 1:28

28 God blessed them and said to them, ‘Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it. Rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky and over every living creature that moves on the ground.’